❖ Art, Science, Therapy
Art, Science, Therapy

Art, Science, Therapy

Historicizing Human Attention in the 20th Century

Julian Chehirian, PhDGuilford College

Fellow, Science History InstituteOctober 28, 2026

John Woolman
John Woolman

Unsigned 18th-century sketchIn 1757, John Woolman wrote a letter to the Friends at New Garden, the meeting from which Guilford College grew.

Woolman, Journal, 1774

the Road to large Business appeared open; but I felt a Stop in my Mind.

nothing might hinder me from the most steady Attention to the Voice of the true Shepherd

I believed Truth required me to live more free from outward Cumbers.

John Woolman, Journal (1774), ch. 3 (1756); ch. 2

Woolman, Journal
Title page, The Journal with other writings of John Woolman

Title page, The Journal with other writings of John Woolman (London: J. M. Dent & Sons; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., 1910)

Scudder, 1910

The Simple Life is then Woolman’s plea

Vida D. Scudder, introduction to John Woolman’s Journal, 1910

Vida D. Scudder (1861–1954)
Vida D. Scudder (1861–1954)
Byung-Chul Han

Byung-Chul Han

The Burnout Society

2010 · English, 2015

Han, 2015
Byung-Chul Han, The Burnout Society (Stanford Briefs, 2015)
Jill Lepore

Jill Lepore

“Burnout: Modern Affliction or Human Condition?”

The New Yorker, May 24, 2021

Lepore, 2021
Jill Lepore, "Burnout: Modern Affliction or Human Condition?"
The Ark, Jaffrey, New Hampshire
The Ark, Jaffrey, New Hampshire
Attention · Art objects · Therapeutics

Attention

Art objects

Therapeutics

Classroom · Museum · Sanatorium

Classroom

Museum

Sanatorium

Attention

Art objects

Therapeutics

Historicizing Attention

Historicizing Attention

Princeton University, spring 2025

Princeton University, spring 2025

Attention and Modernity

Mind, Media and the Senses, 1500–2050

The vocabulary of attention
  • attention span
  • bottleneck
  • cognitive load
  • deficit
  • focus
  • optimize
  • screen time
  • ‑maxxing
Google search
Augustine

Augustine

Confessions

XI.28.38 · c. 400 · attentio

Augustine

I have been scattered into times

Augustine, Confessions XI.29.39 (in tempora dissilui)

X.35.57

A dog coursing a hare.

A lizard catching flies.

Augustine

my love is my weight

Augustine, Confessions XIII.9.10 (pondus meum amor meus)

Christopher Mole

Christopher Mole

“Attention”

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2009; rev. 2026

Mole, Attention (SEP)
Christopher Mole, "Attention," Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Jonathan Crary

Jonathan Crary

Suspensions of Perception

Attention, Spectacle, and Modern Culture · 1999

Crary, 1999
Jonathan Crary, Suspensions of Perception
Simon Schaffer

Simon Schaffer

“Astronomers Mark Time: Discipline and the Personal Equation”

Science in Context 2, 1988

Venus transit, 1876
Tests of observers' relative personalities in Paris, in preparation for the Venus transit of 1876
Kircher's camera obscura
Athanasius Kircher's camera obscura

“Athanasius Kircher’s camera obscura,” illustration from Kircher’s Ars magna lucis et umbrae (1671), reproduced in Josef Maria Eder’s Ausführliches Handbuch der Photographie

Crary, 1990

The visible “escapes from the timeless incorporeal order of the camera obscura and becomes lodged in another apparatus, within the unstable physiology and temporality of the human body.”

Jonathan Crary, Techniques of the Observer: On Vision and Modernity in the Nineteenth Century (MIT Press, 1990), 70

Beard, 1881 — p. 13

It is asked why not English, French, German, or Irish nervousness? Our answer is, that while modern nervousness is not peculiar to America, yet there are special expressions of this nervousness that are found here only; and the relative quantity of nervousness and of nervous diseases that spring out of nervousness, are far greater here than in any other nation of history, and it has a special quality. American nervousness, like American invention or agriculture, is at once peculiar and pre-eminent.

George M. Beard, American Nervousness, 1881, p. 13

George M. Beard (1839–1883)
George M. Beard (1839–1883)
Mitchell, 1877 — p. 33

It is needful to disentangle them from the meshes of old habits and to remove them from the contact with those who have been the willing slaves of their caprices.

S. Weir Mitchell, Fat and Blood, 1877, ch. 3, “Seclusion,” p. 33

Silas Weir Mitchell (1829–1914)
Silas Weir Mitchell (1829–1914)
Ribot, 1896 — p. 2

an apparatus formed by cultivation, and a product of civilization

an exceptional, abnormal state, which cannot last a long time

Ribot, The Psychology of Attention, 3rd ed., 1896, p. 2

Théodule Ribot (1839–1916)
Théodule Ribot (1839–1916)
James, 1890 — p. 403

Every one knows what attention is.

volition is nothing but attention

William James, The Principles of Psychology, vol. 1, 1890, p. 403; p. 447

William James (1842–1910)
William James (1842–1910)
James, 1890 — p. 404

a sort of solemn sense of surrender to the empty passing of time

James, The Principles of Psychology, vol. 1, 1890, p. 404

Attention and the Art Object

Attention and the Art Object

1796 · Hubert Robert, the Grande Galerie of the Louvre
Hubert Robert, the Grande Galerie of the Louvre, 1796
Benjamin

…the secular cult of beauty, developed during the Renaissance and prevailing for three centuries, clearly showed that ritualistic basis in its decline…

Walter Benjamin, “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction,” trans. Harry Zohn, section IV

Benjamin, cover
Walter Benjamin, The Artwork in the Age of its Technical Reproducibility

Cover, The Artwork in the Age of its Technical Reproducibility

Bishop, 2024

…aims to move beyond the moralising binary of attention/distraction… to rethink contemporary spectatorship as neither good nor bad but perpetually hybrid and collective.

Claire Bishop, Disordered Attention: How We Look at Art and Performance Today (Verso, 2024), introduction

Bishop, cover
Claire Bishop, Disordered Attention
Odell, 2019 — p. 6

Odell describes art as an “attention-holding architecture”.

How to Do Nothing
Jenny Odell, How to Do Nothing: Resisting the Attention Economy
Scott Polach, Applause Encouraged, 2015
Scott Polach, Applause Encouraged, Cabrillo National Monument, San Diego, 2015
Laboratory room at Harvard University, c. 1893
Laboratory room at Harvard University, c. 1893
Titchener's Lab at Cornell
Psychological Laboratory, floor plan
Speculative Psychotechnics
c. 1891 · Thomas Eakins, Miss Amelia Van Buren
Thomas Eakins, Miss Amelia Van Buren, c. 1891
c. 1910 · Thomas Wilmer Dewing, Lady in White (No. 1)
Thomas Wilmer Dewing, Lady in White (No. 1), c. 1910
Ruskin (1819–1900)
John Ruskin (1819–1900)
Ruskin, 1853

We have much studied and much perfected, of late, the great civilized invention of the division of labor; only we give it a false name. It is not, truly speaking, the labor that is divided; but the men:—Divided into mere segments of men—broken into small fragments and crumbs of life; so that all the little piece of intelligence that is left in a man is not enough to make a pin, or a nail, but exhausts itself in making the point of a pin, or the head of a nail.

John Ruskin, The Stones of Venice, vol. 2, 1853, ch. 6, §16

Morris (1834–1896)
William Morris (1834–1896)
Lears, 1981
Jackson Lears, No Place of Grace: Antimodernism and the Transformation of American Culture, 1880–1920
Morris, 1884

Nothing should be made by man’s labour which is not worth making; or which must be made by labour degrading to the makers.

William Morris, “Art and Socialism” (1884)

Arts and Crafts Movement
Kelmscott Manor, frontispiece to William Morris, News from Nowhere

Frontispiece, News from Nowhere, or An Epoch of Rest (Kelmscott Press, 1892); design C. M. Gere, engraving W. H. Hooper

Morris, 1884

A man at work, making something which he feels will exist because he is working at it and wills it, is exercising the energies of his mind and soul as well as of his body.

William Morris, “Useful Work versus Useless Toil” (1884)

Interior
Interior with books, from William Morris's house
Therapeutics

Therapeutics

The Making Cure

The Making Cure: Healing Attention, from Neurasthenia to ADHD recovers a forgotten counterpart to psychoanalysis’s talking cure: a lineage of practitioners, shaped by progressive education, the fine arts, and American pragmatism, who held that a disordered mind could be remade not by interpreting its symbols but by retraining what it chose to attend to. Following their art and occupational therapies through American sanatoria, psychiatric hospitals, and schools, the book re-reads art in the clinic as a chapter in the history of attention and psychotechnics.

Three attention therapies

Diverting: Marblehead, 1904

Floating: New York, 1941

Rationalizing: Washington, 1947

Herbert J. Hall (1870–1923)
Herbert J. Hall (1870–1923)
Jessie Luther (1860–1952)
Jessie Luther (1860–1952)
Mitchell, 1877
S. Weir Mitchell, Fat and Blood: and How to Make Them, title page
Luther, 1899

…when methods are constantly invented for substituting the machine for the hand, thereby forcing the hand simply to become a part of the machine itself, without thought, will, or ingenuity, there has come a reaction, a reversion to hand industry… for the development and co-ordination of hand and brain.

Luther, c. 1899–1900, as quoted in Rompkey, Jessie Luther at the Grenfell Mission, 2001, p. xxvi

Cover, 1908
Elwood Worcester, Samuel McComb and Isador H. Coriat, Religion and Medicine: The Moral Control of Nervous Disorders (1908)
Boyd
Thomas Parker Boyd, How and Why of the Emmanuel Movement
Religion and Medicine, 1908
Religion and Medicine: "the will is nothing but a selective action or reaction to certain ideas"

Religion and Medicine, 1908

Worcester
Elwood Worcester (1862–1940)

Elwood Worcester (1862–1940)

Occupational therapy
Workers in the Handcraft Shop, Marblehead
Hall and Buck, 1915 — pp. 177–178

Her attention was entirely taken up with her own condition

somewhat monotonous and mechanical

She caned eight chairs in a fortnight, and soon after was able to return home.

Hall and Buck, The Work of Our Hands, 1915, pp. 177–178

The Work of Our Hands
The Work of Our Hands, cover
Work of Our Hands, p. 172
The Work of Our Hands, p. 172: "Her attention was successfully diverted from her illness"

The Work of Our Hands, 1915, p. 172

The Work of Our Hands
The Work of Our Hands, cover

The Work of Our Hands (1915)

Work of Our Hands, p. 92
The Work of Our Hands, p. 92: "to open new channels of thought, and to clear out the débris from long disused ones"
Weaving room, Devereux Sanatorium, Marblehead
Weaving room, Devereux Sanatorium, Marblehead

“Weaving room. Twenty-four hand looms in a big converted barn. An ideal occupation room; plenty of air and light.” Devereux Sanatorium in Marblehead, MA (1904–1914)

Hall and Buck, 1915 — p. 76

May 1, 1914

Occupation work

        Mrs. X — Room 50

        Light occupation in bed.

        Basketry or Knitting.

        Not more than 1 hour daily.

                        ————————, M.D.

Hall and Buck, The Work of Our Hands, 1915, p. 76

Hall and Buck, 1915 — p. 77

May 1, 1914

Occupation work

        Mr. D — Ward 2

        Occupation in workshop.

        Heavy Work. 3 hours daily.

        Running Printing Press.

                        ————————, M.D.

Hall and Buck, The Work of Our Hands, 1915, p. 77

Russell, "Occupational Formulary," 1938, p. 34
Russell, "Occupational Formulary," 1938, p. 34
Three attention therapies

Diverting: Marblehead, 1904

Floating: New York, 1941

Rationalizing: Washington, 1947

Naumburg (1890–1983)
Margaret Naumburg (1890–1983)
Naumburg, cover
Margaret Naumburg, Dynamically Oriented Art Therapy: Its Principles and Practice
An Introduction
Margaret Naumburg, An Introduction to Art Therapy

Cover, An Introduction to Art Therapy

Naumburg, Figure 9
Modelled figures by the patient John, from Naumburg
Three attention therapies

Diverting: Marblehead, 1904

Floating: New York, 1941

Rationalizing: Washington, 1947

Taylor (1907–1991)
Prentiss Taylor (1907–1991)
Howard Hall, 1947
Ann Boyle
Ann Boyle standing in front of her work: "Art: A Therapy That Works. Ann Boyle Is An Artist, Poet and Mental Patient"

By Judy Luce Mann; Washington Post Staff Writer · The Washington Post (1974-); May 28, 1975

Ann Boyle
Newspaper clipping on Ann Boyle, artist, poet and patient at Saint Elizabeths Hospital, with two passages boxed in red

By Judy Luce Mann; Washington Post Staff Writer · The Washington Post (1974-); May 28, 1975

Query

Query

Google search
Scudder, 1910

the hopelessness of the attempt to achieve, by individual means and private effort, a satisfying social righteousness in an unchanged world

Vida D. Scudder, introduction to John Woolman’s Journal, 1910

Friends of Attention

We are part of a rising movement for freedom, and that movement needs places and times where true and beautiful and actually human attention can escape the deranging and exploitative pressures of the digital frackosphere — and plant the seeds of the world we want.

The Friends of Attention, letter “Dear Friend,” Penguin Random House Library, December 5, 2025 (authors of Attensity!)

1

What, in our common life, is cumber?

2

What do we want our attention to be for?

3

When have you seen students’ attention held, and not just captured?